The Japanese Association of School Health

Research Note

ISSN ONLINE : 1880-2400

[School Health Vol.15, 25-33, 2019]

Exploring the Factors Associated with the Survey Participation of Parents: Does a Cooperation Reward Increase Their Response Rate?

Noboru Iwata*

  • *Faculty of Health Care, Kiryu University
  • 606 Azami, Kasakake-Cho, Midori, Gunma, 379-2392, Japan
  • iwata-no@kiryu-u.ac.jp

[Received February 1, 2018 ; Accepted December 21, 2018]

Keywords:
questionnaire survey, parents, response rate, elementary school, cooperation reward

Free PDF

Abstracts

Background: In the case of survey research, it is important to consider the sampling method and increase response rates for the survey to enhance the representativeness of the surveyed sample. Of several strategies, a monetary incentive has been widely known as the most effective way to increase response rates. However, this finding has been derived mainly from social surveys in the western countries, and little is known about the difference in response rates with and without a monetary incentive in the field of school health research.

Objective: This study aimed to clarify the influence of cooperation reward and other related factors on the response rate of a parent survey.

Methods: From late September to early October of 2016, a self-administered questionnaire survey was conducted for 5th- and 6th-grade students and their homeroom teachers in eight public elementary schools as well as their parents in six schools in four areas of A prefecture. In the student survey, a questionnaire was distributed by the homeroom teachers, responded to by the students in the class, and collected in individual envelopes after sealing. In the parent survey, students brought survey forms and two envelopes home to their fathers and mothers, and their parents individually completed the surveys and sealed the envelopes, and the students brought them to school. In addition, except for some elementary schools, we prepared a “Quo-Card” for a cooperation reward.

Results: Of the parent surveys conducted with 434 families in 6 elementary schools, both or either father or mother of 278 families cooperated (64%). The response rate in the survey was 78% (195/249) with a cooperation incentive and 45% (83/185) without it, yielding a significant difference (χ2 = 51.58, p < .001).
Combined with the gender of the homeroom teacher, there was no gender difference in response rate when there was a cooperation reward (78% for both), but a significant gender difference was found (34% for male, 65% female) when without it. Some student-level variables significantly correlated with response rate survey cooperation could be regarded as reflecting the situation of well-adjusted students, such as satisfaction with study, fewer academic stressors, and stressors from/with friends, among others.

Conclusion: The response rate improved by about 30% with a cooperation reward, but the influence of teacher's instruction and some other factors could not be ignored.

References

  • 1) Hagihara G, Ota H, Fujii S: An experimental study about survey response rate: Basic study of efficient strategies to raise the participation rate of Mobility Management. Infrastructure Planning Review 23: 117–123, 2006 (in Japanese with English abstract)
  • 2) Umino M, Shinoki M, Kudo T: A study on the effect of the management system of data collection process on collection rate in social survey: The experience of the surveys on waste problem. Advances in Social Research 2: 43–56, 2009 (in Japanese)
  • 3) Kobayashi J, Muto M, Watanabe D et al.: Challenges to 70% response rate: How to minimize contact in mail surveys. Bulletin of Seikei University 49: 1–16, 2015 (in Japanese)
  • 4) Inaba A: Problems relating to declining response rates to social survey research in Japan: Trends after 2000. International Journal of Japanese Sociology 16: 10–22, 2007
  • 5) Kojima H: Experimental research to increase response rates in mail surveys. Japanese Journal of Behaviormetrics 37: 147–157, 2010 (in Japanese with English abstract)
  • 6) Guo Y, Kopec JA, Cibere J et al.: Population survey features and response rates: A randomized experiment. American Journal of Public Health 106: 1422–1426, 2016
  • 7) Church AH: Estimating the effect of incentives on mail survey response rates: A meta-analysis. Public Opinion Quarterly 57: 62–79, 1993
  • 8) Edwards PJ, Roberts I, Clarke MJ et al.: Methods to increase response to postal and electric questionnaires. Cochrane Database Systematic Review 3: MR000008, 2009
  • 9) Doerfling P1, Kopec JA, Liang MH et al.: The effect of cash lottery on response rates to an online health survey among members of the Canadian Association of Retired Persons: a randomized experiment. Canadian Journal of Public Health 101: 251–254, 2010
  • 10) Griffin JM, Simon AB, Hulbert E et al.: A comparison of small monetary incentives to convert survey non-respondents: a randomized control trial. BMC Medical Research Methodology 11: 81, 2011
  • 11) Chin WY, Choi EPH, Lam CLK: The effect of timing of incentive payments on response rates for cohort study telephone interviews in primary care setting with costminimization analysis, a randomized controlled trial. BMC Medical Research Methodology 15:79, 2015
  • 12) Dillman DA: Mail and Internet Surveys: The Tailored Design Method, 2nd Edition, John Wiley & Sons, New York, 2000
  • 13) Kitamura T, Fujihara S, Iwata N et al.: Epidemiology of psychiatric disorders in Japan. In: Nakane Y and Radford M eds., Images in Psychiatry: Japan, 37–46, World Psychiatric Association, Geneva, 1999
  • 14) Kawakami N, Takeshima T, Ono Y et al.: Twelve-month prevalence, severity, and treatment of common mental disorders in communities in Japan: A preliminary finding from the World Mental Health Japan 2002-2003. Psychiatry and Clinical Neurosciences 59: 441–452, 2005
  • 15) National Institute for Youth Education. Dai 1 Shou, Chousa no Gaiyou. Available at: http://www.niye.go.jp/kanri/upload/editor/84/File/dai1shou.pdf. (in Japanese) Accessed January 5, 2018
  • 16) Kanagawa Prefecture. Dai 1 Shou, Chousa no Gaiyou.Available at: http://www.pref.kanagawa.jp/docs/u5t/cnt/f10972/documents/54527.pdf. (in Japanese) Accessed January 5, 2018
  • 17) Nagaoka City. Heisei 25 Nenndo Nagaoka-shi no Jidou Seito, Hogosya, Kyouin Ishiki Chousa, Shukei Kekka–Youyaku Ban. Available at: http://www.city.nagaoka.niigata.jp/kosodate/cate03/file/ishiki-cyosa05.pdf. (in Japanese) Accessed January 5, 2018
  • 18) Suita City. Suita-shi Kodomo no Seikatu ni kansuru Jittai Chousa Houkoku ni tuite. Available at: http://www.city.suita.osaka.jp/home/soshiki/div-jidou/kateijido/_71889.html. (in Japanese) Accessed January 5, 2018
  • 19) Oh AY, Davis T, Dwyer LA et al.: Recruitment, enrollment, and response of parent-adolescent dyads in the FLASHE Study. American Journal of Preventive Medicine 52: 849–855, 2017
  • 20) Kimura H: Gakko-tooshi ni yoru Shitsumonshi-Chousa no Kanousei to Genkai. Special Issue, Schools as Research Fields. Advances in Social Research 2: 28–34, 2009 (in Japanese)
  • 21) Yamasaki K, Uchida K: Problems of the development and administration of questionnaires in psychological survey studies. Research Bulletin of Educational Sciences, Naruto University of Education 20: 1–10, 2005 (in Japanese with English abstract)
  • 22) Matsuishi T, Nagano M, Araki Y et al.: Scale properties of the Japanese version of the strengths and difficulties questionnaire (SDQ): A study of infant and school children in community samples. Brain and Development 30: 410–415, 2008
  • 23) Goodman R, Ford T, Simmons H et al.: Using the strengths and difficulties questionnaire (SDQ) to screen for child psychiatric disorders in a community sample. British Journal of Psychiatry 177: 534–539, 2000
  • 24) Okayasu T, Shimada H, Sakano Y: Development of stress response scale for junior high school students. Waseda Journal of Human Sciences 5: 23–29, 1992 (in Japanese with English abstract)
  • 25) Sakano Y, Okayasu T, Shimada H: PSI Public Health Research Foundation Type Stress Inventory. Jitsumu Kyouiku Shuppan, Tokyo, 2007 (in Japanese)
  • 26) Ishige M, Muto T: Psychological well-being, resilience, and social support expectancy: Junior high school students facing high school entrance examinations. Japanese Journal of Educational Psychology 53: 356–367, 2005 (in Japanese with English abstract)
  • 27) Faul F, Erdfelder E, Lang A‑G et al.: G*Power 3: A flexible statistical power analysis program for the social, behavioral, and biomedical sciences. Behavior Research Methods 39: 175–191, 2007
  • 28) American Psychological Association. Publication manual of the American Psychological Association, 5th ed. Washington, DC: Author; 2005
  • 29) Okamoto Y. Hi no Sa no Bunsan Bunseki. Available at: http://homepage2.nifty.com/okamotoy/anovap/ (in Japanese) Accessed January 5, 2018
  • 30) Matsuoka R, Maeda T: A study of survey non-response using the 13th nationwide survey of the Japanese national character: Assessing sampled individuals', neighborhood' and survey takers' characteristics associated with non-response behavior. Proceedings of the Institute of Statistical Mathematics 63: 229–242, 2015 (in Japanese with English abstract)

▲ Go to top of page