The Japanese Association of School Health

Paper

ISSN ONLINE : 1880-2400

[School Health Vol.4, 24-39, 2008]

Meta-analytic Study of Gender Differences in Motor Performance and Their Annual Changes among Japanese Preschool-aged Children

Takahiro Ikeda*,** and Osamu Aoyagi***

  • *Department of Early Childhood Education and Care, Saga Junior College
  • 3-18-15 Kamizono, Saga 840-0806 Japan
  • ikeda@saga-jc.ac.jp
  • **Graduate School of Health and Sport Science, Fukuoka University
  • 8-19-1 Nanakuma, Jyonanku Fukuoka 814-0180 Japan
  • ***Faculty of Health and Sport Science, Fukuoka University
  • 8-19-1 Nanakuma, Jyonanku Fukuoka 814-0180 Japan

[Received April 11, 2008 ; Accepted June 24, 2008]

Keywords:
Effect Size, Meta Analysis, Movement Pattern, Test Item of Motor Ability

Free PDF

Abstracts

The aim of the present study was to investigate the gender differences in motor performance, movement patterns, movement skills, and physical fitness and their annual changes among Japanese children. To examine gender differences, a meta-analysis was conducted. A total of 1830 effect sizes were calculated using children’s motor abilities reported in 100 published articles. Based on these effect sizes, 44 test items were conducted on a yearly basis. The integrated effect sizes were also calculated for movement patterns, movement skills, and physical fitness each year. Only 22 of 44 test items showed any gender difference. Based on the annual change in gender differences for each item, the following three patterns were observed: "test items that improve with growth among male children", "test items that remain constant over time among female children" and "test items with no specific gender difference". In gender differences and their annual changes for movement patterns, movement skills, and physical fitness, it was found that male children’s manipulation, walking, and throwing exceeds those of female children; however, excel in locomotion, manipulation with a ball, muscular endurance, and balance. The items in which male children surpassed female children appeared at higher ages and increased with growth. Furthermore, items in which female children excelled emerged at lower ages and disappeared with growth. These differences are considered to be the result of the precocious development of female children in comparison with male children. However, the items in which male children surpassed female children are thought to be considerably influenced by motor experiences.

References

  • Aoyagi, O. (1987) A study of literatures on the motor performance in childhood. Fukuoka University Review of Physical Education 17 (2): 1-9. (in Japanese)
  • Aoyagi, O. (2006) Growth and Development of Children and Human Health. Nakanishiya-shuppan; Kyoto, P.26. (in Japanese)
  • Cohen, J. (1969) Statistical power analysis for the behavioral science. Academic Press: New York.
  • Demura, S. (1993) Contribution of physical fitness and throw form to ball-throw distance and sex difference in preschool children. Japan Journal of Physical Education, Health and Sport Sciences 37: 339-350. (in Japanese with English abstract)
  • Demura, S. (1995) Development and sexual differences of static and dynamic balance in preschool children. Japan Journal of Physical Education, Health and Sport Sciences 40: 67-79.
  • Demura, S., Murase, T. and Okajima, Y. (1990) Development of Motor Ability by Sex Difference in Preschool Children. Japanese journal of school health 32: 532-538. (in Japanese with English abstract)
  • Gallahue, D.L. and Donnelly, F.C. (2003) Development physical education for all children, 4th.Human Kinetics: Champaign, pp. 24-49.
  • Hedge, L.V. (1981) Distribution theory for Glass's estimator of effect size and related estimators. Journal of Educational Statistics 6: 107-128.
  • Ikeda, T. and Aoyagi, O. (2006) A selection of test items for children’s physical and motor fitness: Classification and investigation of test items based on Gallahue’s model of fundamental movement skills. Kyushu Journal of Physical Education and Sports 21 (2): 1-16 (in Japanese with English abstract)
  • Inoue, K. (2000) Development of motor abilities. Kondo, M. (ed. Supervision) The new Motor Play for Babies and Infants 3rd edition. Kenpaku-sha: Tokyo, pp.13-16. (in Japanese)
  • Katsube, A. (1979) The Theory and Practice in Physical Education for Preschool Children revision. Kyorin-shoin: Tokyo, pp.48-49. (in Japanese)
  • Kawahara, Y., Hatakeyama, T. and Funakawa, H. (1981) Development and evaluation of motor functions of children. Memoirs of the Japan Women's University. Faculty of Home Economics 28: 121-130. (in Japanese with English abstract)
  • Kobayashi, K. (1987) Motor instruction and effects in children. Bessatsu Hattatsu [The development separate volume] 6: 167-177. (in Japanese)
  • Kurimoto, E., Asami, T., Shibukawa, R., Matsuura, Y. and Katsube, A. (1981) The final version of the field test of motor coordination by Research Center in Physical Education; The report of Committee of Motor Coordination. Report of Research Center in Physical Education 9: 207-212. (in Japanese)
  • Malina, R. M. and Bouchard, C. (1991) Growth, maturation, and physical activity. Human Kinetics Books:Champaign, pp.187-204.
  • Matsuda, I. (1961) Studies on motor development during early childhood. Bulletin of the Faculty of Physical Education, Tokyo University of Education 1: 38-53. (in Japanese with English abstract)
  • Matsuda, I. and Kondo, M. (1968) A study on the motor abilities of preschool children; a composition of a standard of the development of the motor abilities of preschool children. Bulletin of the Faculty of Physical Education, Tokyo University of Education 7: 33-45. (in Japanese with English abstract)
  • Matsui, M., Matsuda, I. and Mori, K. (1955) Studies on motor ability tests for children. Research Journal of Physical Education 9:523-533. (in Japanese)
  • Matsuura, Y. (1982) Development of physical fitness. Asakura-shoten: Tokyo. pp.43-44. (in Japanese)
  • Miyaji, K., Katsube, A. and Harada, S. (1970) The studies on the motor ability of kindergarten children (Part 1). Annual report of Natural Science and Home Economics, Kinjo Gakuin College 11: 31-44. (in Japanese with English abstract)
  • Mullen, B. (1989) Advanced BASIC meta-analysis. Lawrence Erlbaum Associates: New Jersey, pp.1-14.
  • Murase, T. and Demura, S. (2005) Discussion on further studies to measure and evaluate fitness and motor performance for preschool children; summary and previous studies in Japan and future consideration. Japan Journal of Test and Evaluation of Physical Education and Sports 5: 5-13. (in Japanese with English abstract)
  • Nakamura, E. and Matsuura, Y. (1979) The development of fundamental motor ability of boys and girls aged four to eight. Japan Journal of Physical Education, Health and Sport Science 24: 127-135. (in Japanese with English abstract)
  • Nakamura, S., Tsunoda, S., Sugiyama, M., Funato, N., Yoshimura, T. and Miyazaki, M. (1980) A study on teaching physical education in kindergarten: part five.The Annual Report of Physical Education12: 16-27. (in Japanese with English abstract)
  • Nishijima, N. (2005) Motor ability test for children. Growth and Development of Children 3 (2): 70-77. (in Japanese)
  • Otaki, T. (1978) Development of physics, motor abilities and mind. Ikuta, S. and Imaizumi, N. (Ed.) Instruction of Health for Babies and Infants, Kitaohji-shobo: Kyoto, pp.42-44. (in Japanese)
  • Shiba, S. and Haebara, T. (1990) Methods of statistical analysis for behavioral science. University of Tokyo Press: Tokyo, pp.245-252. (in Japanese)
  • Sparling, P.B. (1980) A meta-analysis of studies comparing maximal oxygen uptake in men and woman. Research Quarterly for Exercise and Sport 51:542-552.
  • Sugihara, T. Kondo, M., Mori, S. and Yoshida, I (2004) Children’s Motor abilities by national research in 2002. Journal of Health, Physical Education and Recreation 54: 161-170. (in Japanese)
  • Takeuchi, H. and Tateishi, A. (1993) The body and motor function of children. Kindai-bungeisha: Tokyo, pp.124-130. (in Japanese)
  • Tamiaki, G. and Akimaru, T. (2003) The Contents of Child Care. Kitaohji-shobo: Kyoto, pp.44-46. (in Japanese)
  • Tomas, J.R. and French, K.E. (1985) Gender differences across age in motor performance: A meta-analysis. Psychological Bulletin 98:260-282.
  • Tomas, J.R. and Nelson, J.K. (2001) Research methods in physical activity. Human Kinetics: Champaign, pp.237-259.
  • Ueda, R. (1986) How do Human Develop?; Thinking on Growth of Adults and Children. Kodansha: Tokyo, pp.149-150. (in Japanese)
  • Yoshizawa, S. (2002) Aerobic capacity in young children. Kyorin-shoin: Tokyo, pp.30-31. (in Japanese)

▲ Go to top of page